Testing the water - does this work for you ?

[snatcher]

Been messing around in Photoshop with a sunrise shot I took down at Whitley Bay Table Rocks. Was simply looking to "highlight" the reflection in this picture. Does it work for you ?

Honest opinions appreciated - I have thick skin,its ok.



John

 

[regpude]

different

different

Been messing around in Photoshop with a sunrise shot I took down at Whitley Bay Table Rocks. Was simply looking to "highlight" the reflection in this picture. Does it work for you ?

Honest opinions appreciated - I have thick skin,its ok.



John

cant really say john just different thats all i can say.suppose the origanal photo posted aswell would of been better to give our opinions.ps,pleased your thick skinned like myself.i wouldent even be able to take a photo never mind mess about with them.

 

[onefortheroad]

its very similar to regpude - different

 

[snatcher]

Here is the original for comparison



John

 

[phill_itofish]

I prefer the original John, although the edited version looks like something out of Sin City

 

[tonyfromalnwick]

I like it.
Is there any way you could put the colour from the reflection into the sea as well ?

 

[regpude]

What

What

its very similar to regpude - different

you mean im thick skinned.bit banter doesent hurt? lol.

 

[snatcher]

I like it.
Is there any way you could put the colour from the reflection into the sea as well ?

Yes,not too difficult Tony

John

 

[The Jester]

The original for me as well...

 

[regpude]

The original for me as well...

me aswell original.

 

[Bob C]

You asked for Honesty & honestly, its a mess. The original is way better imo.
Easy to lose your way with Photoshop & go over the top.

 

[Pighunter]

There both better than I can do. I like the first one as it's different

 

[tonybax]

prefer the original john

 

[kayos]

I think the original is amazing, award winning even. Why mess about with perfection? Wish I could take photos like that!

 

[Leej]

I think the original is amazing, award winning even. Why mess about with perfection? Wish I could take photos like that!

I agree , cracking photo

 

[Charlton]

Hi John
only thing good about the first one is, the sky reflecting on the water which is part of the original the rest in my honest humble opinion is crap. Would try and lighten the rocks in the original around the pool to see if you can give them some texture.

 

[Davey1970]

mr Charlton,

some people have feeling's you know.

 

[Charlton]

mr Charlton,

some people have feeling's you know.

he wanted honest opinions didn't he and I was being diplomatic wasn't I

 

[Davey1970]

he wanted honest opinions didn't he and I was being diplomatic wasn't I

a take it we won't be seeing the picture in 1 of your article's alan.

 

[Charlton]

a take it we won't be seeing the picture in 1 of your article's alan.

no there is no fish in it