anyone know why

[big phil 123]

Certain comps ban certain baits? I understan that not everyone can afford white worm and crab but why should the people who can be penalized its like saying you cant use a certain rod or reel because not everyone can afford them either is there another reason?i understand about cart but why certain natural baits such as crab ot white worm banned anyine kniw?

 

[toonboymc]

Very good question Phil
To me you should be able to use everything from cart to crabsticks

 

[big phil 123]

Very good question Phil
To me you should be able to use everything from cart to crabsticks

I agree if lads want to spend the money on shipping crab up from devon then fair play or have put the time in to get white rag why penalize them?

 

[scaley]

its to try and get more lads to fish the comps, and why spend money on good bait when you can catch flats on blacks/rag and mackeral. people think its because the lads who run the comps cant get crab and whites when really they have tires and have plenty of bait suppliers to sort them out with whites but there is no need to use them for flounders anyway as most baits will work just fine for them but all baits have their days

 

[Mad as a fish]

Maybe they think certian baits that are hard to get give an unfair advantage

 

[safc]

They only ban crab when its out of season

Translates in english to " we cant get so you cant use it"

 

[scaley]

no its banned in the summer in most pegged matches

 

[Philysafc]

It gives the once a week fisherman a chance and increases participants in comps, if all baits where allowed 30 / 40% of anglers wouldnt compete .

 

[beachbuddy]

They only ban crab when its out of season

Translates in english to " we cant get so you cant use it"

The copthorne comp ban was crab/whites and maddies that was the other week.

 

[safc]

The copthorne comp ban was crab/whites and maddies that was the other week.

Well thats just silly then, theyve banned two of the 3 baits that actually fish that far up river

 

[scaley]

but as i said and also philly said its to get more anglers onto the matches

 

[billynobaits]

It's fair enough,in my opinion.Your comp,your rules,if anyone isn't happy,
they don't have to fish.
The popularity or otherwise with the rules,will determine how successful
a competition is,by the number of participants.

 

[Mogthemackem]

A lot of these matcha anglers use imported continental rods now. Think they would be gutted if all rods over 14ft were banned for comps. Stupid rules as everyone can have an advantage over the next person whether it be bait, additives, equipment, tackle and knowledge. It's kind of like telling premier league footballers they can only use their left foot in the first couple of rounds of the fa cup as they have too big an advantage over non-league teams. Unfortunately nothing is democratic any more so we just have to suck it up and accept Phil as their comebacks will always be "you dont have to fish it"

 

[big phil 123]

A lot of these matcha anglers use imported continental rods now. Think they would be gutted if all rods over 14ft were banned for comps. Stupid rules as everyone can have an advantage over the next person whether it be bait, additives, equipment, tackle and knowledge. It's kind of like telling premier league footballers they can only use their left foot in the first couple of rounds of the fa cup as they have too big an advantage over non-league teams. Unfortunately nothing is democratic any more so we just have to suck it up and accept Phil as their comebacks will always be "you dont have to fish it"

Fully agree i know hossack gets alot of stick for getting fresh crab in winter but why should he and others be penalized for having the best bait i think they should allow any bait or even better everyone has the same bait in the peg matches especially. I read about a beach comp some were everyone had the same bait and the same amount and the skill was using your bait sensible. No good for me as i try to choke the fish but though it was a good idea. Everyone can get silvers and crab its just if you want to pay the money for it same as rods and reels

 

[Deans]

pay money for big silvers.

yes please. who . where. how much .


thats fair

 

[The Spaniard]

Fully agree i know hossack gets alot of stick for getting fresh crab in winter but why should he and others be penalized for having the best bait i think they should allow any bait or even better everyone has the same bait in the peg matches especially. I read about a beach comp some were everyone had the same bait and the same amount and the skill was using your bait sensible. No good for me as i try to choke the fish but though it was a good idea. Everyone can get silvers and crab its just if you want to pay the money for it same as rods and reels

Do you fish them Phil ?

 

[big phil 123]

The opens and a few peg matches when i get time was just asking if there was another reason why certain baits were banned i know about cart and as its illegal fair enough but to say baits are to expensive when you have the match lads using rods that most have not even hurd of them

 

[The Spaniard]

It's not the rod it's who is on the end of it...

 

[big phil 123]

It's not the rod it's who is on the end of it...

Agreed so why ban certain baits i dont understand why

 

[The Spaniard]

To keep it fair to all anglers and make it a competition