hi there,
if you are fishing up at oban on the charter boats i suggest you use the gear and traces supplied, the rods you suggest just won\'t cut it in these waters as you will be fishing in a minimum of 300 feet or more likely 400-500 feet of water with a minimum of 2lb of lead.
if it\'s ireland i think they fish much shallower and with lighter tides so you could with care fish lighter, but you should aim to land these fish as quickly as possible to minimise the stress on them.
i don\'t profess to be an expert at skate fishing but i have had a few, my current tackle i use for them is a penn 5\' 9\" 80lb class standup rod teamed with a TLD25 and a 6\' 80lb class standup rod also teamed with a TLD25 i built this rod myself from a prototype conoflex blank i got from a friend of mine who is a consultant with them from time to time, he\'s actually giving me the 50lb class sister blank for this rod to build up soon as the 3rd rod i bought for skate exploded on the first fish it hooked, this was a cheap rod i got from ebay, a masterline 80lb standup crappy stick snapped in 2 places 5 minutes into the fight
for the best advice you should contact davy holt, he looks into this site from time to time, but he has his own site www.catchalot.co.uk
if you are fishing from a small boat let me know and i\'ll give you a few pointers
regards
les