Bit of a difficult one this, I don\'t know enough about Seabait to comment on their business, other than there are much better options available in terms of ragworm. Many anglers stopped using it down here quite a few years ago and the Welsh farmed rag is superior in quality.
The Welsh farmed ragworm is pretty reliable and I would think that local dealers would look to this to fill any gaps vacated by Seabait’s downsizing of their UK operation. I suspect that once anglers get used to using farmed ragworm other than Seabait, they would probably prefer it and the local tackle dealers would almost certainly order just the Welsh rag, so this sounds a bit like commercial suicide for seabait.
The NFSA cannot interfere with privately owned businesses, nor should they. If Seabait have broken company law or are in breach of any grant or subsidy requirements then clarification from the issuing body will be needed. However, I would be extremely surprised if a company of Seabait\'s standing would wilfully and knowingly breach any such regulation or grant condition. Downsizing operations in a specific market and moving the emphasis to another, is in itself not an illegal manoeuvre.
If they were instrumental in getting Budle Bay closed to bait digging, I’m surprised that anglers were so willing to use their product, as it appears to have been an obvious business tactic. From what little I know about the Budle Bay bait digging case, English Nature and the RSPB were also heavily involved. Does Budle Bay not abut the Lindisfarne Nature reserve?
If directors are selling off their assets, and closing a market to satisfy another market, it seems to me that they are unable to compete and maintain the supply in the UK and are having to put all their eggs into one basket, it sounds like they are in trouble.
To be honest Alan, unless there are health or live transportation issues, the government will not prevent Seabait from exporting live ragworm. The fact that they have decided to source an alternative market, is not a valid reason to prevent them from doing so. The grants I’m sure will be non-refundable, or if they are, given the time the company has been in business, they are likely to have been paid back in any case. Finally, there is a cold day in hell’s chance of getting Budle Bay opened again, it is an intergral component of SAC,s SSSI and SPA (in others words an area of high nature conservation importance), from the conservation bodies perspective to give open access would be a significant retrospective step and one which they would fight all the way, and supported by the government.
We are far better off putting all our energy into fighting for issues which we have a reasonable chance of winning and to protect access to areas which may be put forward as conservation or protected areas in the future.
For what its worth, it is possible that Seabait cannot compete with other farmed suppliers in the UK, given its strong base in the NE, other suppliers have not had an opportunity to exploit that market, however, they have expanded in all other areas of the UK squeezing Seabait out and restricting it now to its home base. Having lost a significant proportion of its market, Seabait appear to be having a last ditch attempt to survive, resulting in putting all its effort in to overseas markets, as the UK market has gone.
I will pass on the message to HQ but don’t expect any significant response in terms of financial assistance for solicitors and or lawyers fees.
Cheers
Doc.