So Shields Open Result

[sless]

hear say hear say hear say,arm chair anglers you get them all

the lad was not disqualified,he asked at the weigh in if the fish could be weighed in
they were not weighed in
so no cheating took place

 

[nrgjim]

hear say hear say hear say,arm chair anglers you get them all

the lad was not disqualified,he asked at the weigh in if the fish could be weighed in
they were not weighed in
so no cheating took place

thanks for that sless and me and daz had loads of wyts on monday night and one canny dab

 

[super-MAGuire]

A good post terry. I didn't want to mention it this morning when i was in, however, i was aware of situations and curious. But that sets the storys straight.

Thanks for the insight and information.

 

[flatheed]

If a police officer says it is ok to run a red light or go the wrong way down a one way street, does it make it legal?? The fact he should know better does not invalidate the law. The fact the lad was advised he could carry on, in error as it happens doesnt make the disqualification incorrect.

All the other points are side issues. Other guys on the pier before and not disqualified, climbing the gates etc etc. Unfortunately for the lad I believe the correct decision was made. The lads on the committee, I'm sure, knew they were in for a rough ride when that call was made and so it has proved. Correct nonetheless.

 

[jimmy]

If a police officer says it is ok to run a red light or go the wrong way down a one way street, does it make it legal?? QUOTE]

But what if that officer phones the cheif superintendant for guidance, and the chief super says yes its ok, run the red light then, i would

 

[kingcod deano]

If a police officer says it is ok to run a red light or go the wrong way down a one way street, does it make it legal?? QUOTE]

But what if that officer phones the cheif superintendant for guidance, and the chief super says yes its ok, run the red light then, i would

Now that makes sense

 

[jimmy]

Now that makes sense

it does, doesnt it mate, funny enough am in court on friday for speeding through a red light hahahahahaha

 

[flatheed]

If a police officer says it is ok to run a red light or go the wrong way down a one way street, does it make it legal?? QUOTE]

But what if that officer phones the cheif superintendant for guidance, and the chief super says yes its ok, run the red light then, i would

Still doesnt make it legal Jimmy. Thats my point, if the advice given is incorrect it does not the invalidate the law/rules no matter who says its ok. The lad has a right to be annoyed due to the advice he was given but that advice does not bring about a change to the rules.

By the way I wouldnt ask a chief supt about the law they know naff all. Paperclip orders and the way to the pop machine maybe.

..... and I was about to say then youd get done by the polis but I see I was a bit late ;-)

 

[jimmy]

Still doesnt make it legal Jimmy. Thats my point, if the advice given is incorrect it does not the invalidate the law/rules no matter who says its ok. The lad has a right to be annoyed due to the advice he was given but that advice does not bring about a change to the rules.

By the way I wouldnt ask a chief supt about the law they know naff all. Paperclip orders and the way to the pop machine maybe.

i do get ya point mate and i have said from the start he was wrong to be on before 8am, but going by the rules, he was not the only one should have been disqualified,

A didnt ask a chief super, was about 100 yds from an amber and just put me foot down, was late for me fishing hahahahaha

 

[Codcodcod!]

I'll give you a different example.

My mate and I run an open match. I print off last years brochure and sell tickets.

During the week I decide to make an amendment to the rules that white worm is banned. 40 people turn up and I forget to tell most of them. 30 go away non the wiser. They've got the brochure after all.

Lad fishing next to my mate is using whites. He tells him it's ok carry on fishing with them 'I'm the organiser'. He then proceeds in catching the heaviest fish.

He comes back to the weigh in and wins. We both decide to disqualify him.

How is that fair?

 

[flatheed]

i do get ya point mate and i have said from the start he was wrong to be on before 8am, but going by the rules, he was not the only one should have been disqualified,

A didnt ask a chief super, was about 100 yds from an amber and just put me foot down, was late for me fishing hahahahaha

He was the only one that was identiified (as far as I am aware) and admitted it yes. The others, if idenitified should have been disq as well without a doubt. It is however a pointless argument as they werent identified.

You better hope the magistrate is an angler Jimmy!!

 

[jimmy]

He was the only one that was identiified (as far as I am aware) and admitted it yes. The others, if idenitified should have been disq as well without a doubt. It is however a pointless argument as they werent identified.

You better hope the magistrate is an angler Jimmy!!

loads of anglers in bedlington and thats the court i am up in lol, lets hope a magistrate is from the bedlington station club in that case haha

 

[flatheed]

I'll give you a different example.

My mate and I run an open match. I print off last years brochure and sell tickets.

During the week I decide to make an amendment to the rules that white worm is banned. 40 people turn up and I forget to tell most of them. 30 go away non the wiser. They've got the brochure after all.

Lad fishing next to my mate is using whites. He tells him it's ok carry on fishing with them 'I'm the organiser'. He then proceeds in catching the heaviest fish.

He comes back to the weigh in and wins. We both decide to disqualify him.

How is that fair?

I realise your scenario is the same however to quote the Prime Minister "I refer the honourable gentleman to the answer I have previously given". I'm not saying the whole thing is fair, because I have huge sympathy for the lad given the circumstances. I am simply saying giving everything I have read and I have read it all, the correct decision was made.

 

[flatheed]

loads of anglers in bedlington and thats the court i am up in lol, lets hope a magistrate is from the bedlington station club in that case haha

Slip him a few yellowtails and you might get a walk!

 

[g.ordon]

loads of anglers in bedlington and thats the court i am up in lol, lets hope a magistrate is from the bedlington station club in that case haha

lol. Did yer not get the fixed penalty option mate or what?

 

[jimmy]

lol. Did yer not get the fixed penalty option mate or what?

no mate, no options because it was 85 mph on a 40 mph stretch, if you know the area, it was heading north on the felling bypass at heworth roundabout, like i said i was late for fishing hahahaha.

 

[flatheed]

no mate, no options because it was 85 mph on a 40 mph stretch, if you know the area, it was heading north on the felling bypass at heworth roundabout, like i said i was late for fishing hahahaha.

Ouch! Jimmy do you own a bike?? I think you may need one soon, for a while anyway.

 

[g.ordon]

no mate, no options because it was 85 mph on a 40 mph stretch, if you know the area, it was heading north on the felling bypass at heworth roundabout, like i said i was late for fishing hahahaha.

Just tell him you had to floor it to catch the watchie opening the gate mate, yel be ok.

 

[jimmy]

Just tell him you had to floor it to catch the watchie opening the gate mate, yel be ok.

was thinking of saying the inside lane was full of drivers wanting to turn right into pelaw, and as i was coming down outside lane 2 police cars came flying down with blues and twos going and flashing me to get out the way, only way was to get through red light and pull over. Hope the fkrs aint reading this though.

and yes, i haev the bairns old BMX in the garage hahahaha, single speed with stunt pegs on

 

[g.ordon]

was thinking of saying the inside lane was full of drivers wanting to turn right into pelaw, and as i was coming down outside lane 2 police cars came flying down with blues and twos going and flashing me to get out the way, only way was to get through red light and pull over. Hope the fkrs aint reading this though.

and yes, i haev the bairns old BMX in the garage hahahaha, single speed with stunt pegs on

Aye, that should get yer off the red light rap but yev still got to explain the 85 job mate.